One of the key assumptions of Modern Monetary Theory (MMT)
has been referred to (by critics of MMT) as a notional merging of the
monetary and fiscal authorities – the central bank, the department of finance
and the spending departments – under a single heading: Government. This leads to an odd characterization of the effects
of government spending on the money supply.
To see why, let’s start with a fiscal/monetary relation
which does have an effect on the money supply.
Consider what happens when you pay your taxes. You write a cheque to the Receiver General of
Canada, who presents it to your bank for payment. The relevant funds are transferred from your
bank’s account at the Bank of Canada to the account of the Government of Canada
at the B of C. Because Government
Deposits are not part of the Monetary Base, this transfer reduces the Base and,
in a banking system with reserve requirements, where banks are fully loaned up
(so we’re not really talking about the Canadian case – more the US case before
Quantitative Easing) the reduction in the Base forces a reduction in the money
supply. MMT refers to tax increases as
withdrawing money from the economy, and in the sense we’ve just been talking
about the process, they’re right. So
long as your tax payment sits in the Government’s deposits at the central bank,
the money supply has been reduced. (In practice, the Bank of Canada sterilizes this
kind of tax system effect, but that is simply a reflection of the fact that this
sort of transfer does affect the money supply.)
Here, MMT takes an odd twist. MMTers argue that whenever the government spends,
funds are deposited in the central bank accounts of the commercial banks, so
that (on the assumption of binding reserve requirements) the spending is
automatically accompanied by an increase in the money supply. Again, this is formally correct, since the
central bank is making a transfer from accounts which are not part of the
monetary base to accounts which are part of it.
But MMTers then argue that this means that all government spending is
financed by money creation, with no discussion of how the funds got into the
government deposits in the first place. And
they go from this to arguing that this means that all government spending is
actually money-financed anyway, so that MMT is actually a more accurate
description of how government spending works than standard theory is.
The issue here is that MMT does not see government spending
as being constrained by the amount of funds in the government’s deposits at the
central bank. They (or some of them –
it’s not always clear who can be taken as speaking with authority on the
content of MMT) seem to jump next to the view that there are no limits on the
government’s ability to write cheques on its account at the central bank. This is that conflation of the fiscal and
monetary authorities which critics have noted.
In a world in which the monetary and fiscal authorities are separate, it
amounts to assuming that the central bank will always print whatever quantity
of money the government wants to spend.
In other words, MMT assumes that central bank independence is an
illusory concept. That’s a view which mainstream
economists see as having been at the root of a whole lot of inflationary
episodes in a whole lot of times and places.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.