Saturday, June 1, 2019

Interpreting GDP


Japanese GDP grew at an annualized rate of 2.1% in the first quarter of this year, according to the latest estimates, which was much faster than had been expected.  This has not, however, been greeted as a good sign.   As Tim Worstall notes here, the chief reason for the increase in GDP was the fact the fall in imports (M) outweighed that in exports (X), which produced an increase in net exports (X-M) which was large enough to more than cancel out the weak performance of C+I+G. 

This is a result which is almost Trumpian in nature: cut imports and GDP rises.  (Pierre Lemieux has a critical comment on this kind of interpretation here   and Alex Tabarrok has one here.)    If nothing else, it’s a reminder that it’s important to think about what an economic statistic was designed for.  Every introductory macroeconomics textbook makes the point that GDP is not a measure of welfare, however that term might be defined (although very few newsreaders seem to have grasped that point).  That’s also why most proposals for Green GDP measures make no sense – they’re trying to come up with a single sufficient statistic for well-being: one number which we can look at and instantly see whether we, as a society, are better or worse off in some broad sense.  


GDP is a measure of market activity.  It’s what’s on the horizontal axis of an AD/AS diagram, which tells us that its primary function is to say something about inflation and unemployment.  What we’d really like to be adding up for that purpose is expenditure on domestically produced goods, whether consumption goods or investment goods, but we don’t have reliable, timely data at that kind of level (and it’s important to remember that all of the data we’re using here are estimates).  So instead, we take total spending and subtract spending on imported goods, so that what’s left is (an estimate of) aggregate spending on domestically made goods.  Consider the case where total spending on consumption goods remained unchanged, but spending on imports fell.  Then there will have been a shift of spending from imported to domestically produced goods and domestic employment will probably have risen.  But to get this result, that a drop in imports caused employment to rise, it’s necessary that consumption remains unchanged. 

In the recent Japanese case it appears that, even though other components of GDP fell, the drop in imports was large enough that there must have been substitution of domestically produced for foreign made goods.  That doesn’t mean that the anti-import position is generally good policy: we might all emulate Communist era Albania and cut ourselves off from the rest of the world to eliminate imports altogether, but if everyone does that there will also be no exports, since our exports are someone else’s imports.

It’s generally necessary to be careful in interpreting movements in aggregates like GDP, and levels, too.  Consider the case of Ireland where each of exports and imports individually is over 100% of GDP.  It’s also a good idea to treat the most recent releases with caution.  Apparently Japanese GDP figures are prone to being revised more often, and to larger degree, than those of other developed countries.

And, closer to home, we have cases like this.

At the level of provincial GDP, imports refer to goods produced in other countries and also goods produced in other Canadian provinces.  While we don’t have much data on province-level propensities to import, such data as we do have suggests that, for New Brunswick, for example, the marginal propensity to import (i.e. to buy goods which were produced outside the province, whether in the rest of Canada or abroad) is extremely high.  That means that the provincial Keynesian multiplier is going to be small, so that, even though the provincial LM curve will be very flat (because NB is in a monetary union with the rest of Canada), fiscal policy will be a weak tool.  Stimulative policy, then, would probably be better focused on the AS curve than on the AD curve, which offers the temptation to indulge in a lot of bad policy.  But that’s a topic for another post.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.