Friday, June 28, 2019

Modelling International Financial Flow Effects


A number of papers are running stories like this one by Victor Ferreira from the Financial Post, the gist of which is that if the Fed cuts its policy interest rate while the Bank of Canada leaves its unchanged, the Canadian dollar will rise from around 76¢ US, perhaps to 80¢, at which point, the story goes, damage to Canadian exports will force the Bank to cut Canadian interest rates.

It’s by no means an implausible story, but it’s interesting to think about the formal modelling process the Bank would be looking at in deciding what to do.


Consider an open economy ISLM model which is initially in equilibrium, meaning that it’s at the intersection of the IS, LM and FF curves (being on the FF curve means that there’s no pressure for the exchange rate to change).  Now suppose that the Fed reduces American interest rates.  That raises Canadian rates relative to US rates and causes a financial inflow into Canada, which means that the Canadian (r,Y) combination which had previously held the exchange rate constant no longer does: to restore equilibrium to the exchange rate using the interest rate would require a cut in Canadian interest rates.  This shows up on the IS-LM-FF diagram as a downward shift of the FF curve, since what that curve, taken by itself, shows is (r,Y) combinations which hold the exchange rate unchanged.  At the old Canadian rate of interest, the demand for Loonies on the foreign exchange market has shifted to the right – there’s an increased demand for Loonies because of the drop in the US rate of interest – so the equilibrium exchange rate has risen and the market exchange rate will start to rise towards it.  If we wanted to keep the exchange rate at 76¢ we’d have to cut the interest rate; hence the downward shift of the FF curve.  

The best way to think about that is to say that before the US dropped its rates the old (r,Y) combination was associated with goods and money market equilibrium and also with an unchanging Canadian exchange rate.  Now at exactly the same Canadian r and Y values, the exchange rate has started to rise.  The exchange rate rises when we’re above the FF curve, but since the actual values of r and Y haven’t changed (yet), the only way the old (r,Y) combination can be above the FF curve is if the FF curve has shifted down.  (Remember that none of the curves on the IS-LM-FF diagram is a behavioural function – they’re all equilibrium curves.  They don’t show what does happen, only what would have to happen for there to be equilibrium in the sector that they represent.  When we talk about them as if they show what does happen, we’re hiding the assumption that markets will tend to move to equilibrium: i.e. to the relevant point on their equilibrium curves.  Fortunately that assumption holds up when we look at the data.)

So the price of the Loonie on foreign exchange markets is rising because of an inflow of financial capital from the US.  As the Loonie appreciates, Canadian Exports fall and Canadian Imports rise, both of which will tend to shift the IS curve to the left.  That’ll put downward pressure on Canadian interest rates (since the LM curve hasn’t shifted) and the drop in the price of imports will tend to push CPI inflation down, but at the same time, income and employment will tend to fall.  The Bank of Canada doesn’t target the exchange rate in the sense of running a fixed exchange rate policy, but it is aware of the sort of issues we’re talking about here.

The newspaper articles pretty much all assume that the Bank will eventually have to respond by cutting Canadian policy rates, shifting the LM curve to the left.  But what are the numerical factors involved?  The Bank will have to have an estimate of the degree to which the IS curve shifts to the left, meaning that it’ll have to have estimated the elasticity of imports and exports with respect to the exchange rate.  It’ll need to have an estimate of how much market interest rates will tend to drop by themselves – i.e. of the slope of the LM curve – and as that happens, how much any drop in rates might boost investment and consumer spending - i.e. the slope of the IS curve.

Before all of that, of course, it’ll have to have estimated how much the Loonie will rise in response to the interest rate gap.  It might run an equation with the foreign exchange price of the Loonie as the dependent variable, or it might start by estimating equations for international financial capital flows and then go on to estimate the sensitivity of the exchange rate to those flows.  Whichever approach it takes, it’ll have to consider all of the factors which affect the exchange rate – the interest rate differential is clearly one of them, but the Loonie is often referred to as a petro-currency because of the importance of the oil sector to the Canadian economy, so they’d have to include oil price variables and also, ideally, measures of the general attractiveness of the Canadian economy as a place to invest.  

Remember that what we’re really looking at here is factors which affect the demand and supply curves for Loonies to the foreign exchange markets, so we need to include all of those demand and supply-shifting factors in an equation explaining the exchange rate. 

And after estimating all of those factors (including the ISLM ones we mentioned above) plus the lags involved, the Bank will decide whether and when to cut Canadian rates if the Loonie rises to the point where the shift of the IS curve causes an unacceptable drop in aggregate output and rise in unemployment.

It sounds messy, to put it mildly.  That’s why policy makers work with economic models.  Having a model lets us think systematically about what’s going on – lets us make sure we’ve taken account of all of the relevant factors, and the way they interact.  Absent that, it’d be way too easy to overdo a policy adjustment and go from stabilizing the situation to really screwing it up.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.