Saturday, June 22, 2019

MMT and the Theory of the Government Budget Constraint 2


In an earlier post we sketched out a 1970s literature which we argued has a lot in common with Modern Monetary Theory (MMT).  We considered the case where we start at AD/AS equilibrium at an equilibrium level of income where the government’s budget is in balance but where the economy is operating below full employment.   We considered the case where an increase in government spending is used to shift the AD curve to the right, and the resulting deficit is financed by printing money.  In accord with much of the 1970’s literature we assume that the aggregate price level is constant through all of this – that we’re operating on the horizontal segment of the Keynesian AS curve.  They key theoretical point is that the deficit which arises as a result of the fiscal expansion will persist as long as we hold G at the full employment level, and that deficit will have to be financed every period (which really means that G will have to be paid for anew each period) so the money supply will grow continuously even if Y doesn’t change.


We say “if” Y doesn’t change because the 70’s GBC literature is in the ISLM tradition.  A continuing increase in M, as the deficit continues to need to be financed, causes the LM curve to shift to the right continuously.  Because G remains unchanged, the IS curve doesn’t shift again (it shifted to the right at the time of the initial increase in G) so as the LM curve shifts we slide along the IS curve and, while G doesn’t change, the fall in the equilibrium rate of interest causes Investment (I) to increase by an amount which will depend on the slope of the IS curve.  As the LM curve shifts, then, equilibrium income will rise and tax revenue will rise with it.  Since G remains unchanged, the increase in T causes the deficit to shrink, but as long as there is a deficit it will need to be financed and the money supply will continue to increase.  The process will end when the deficit has been eliminated by rising tax revenues.  In the immortal Canadian phrase, government spending has gone up and the deficit has taken care of itself.

At this point, in fact, income might be above the full employment level, but this wasn’t a problem for the basic 1970s literature since it assumed a constant aggregate price level, so no inflationary pressures developed.  In any event, this effect could have been factored into the amount of the original increase in G, so that full employment would be the end of the dynamic process, not the outcome of the first period increase in G.

Our new balanced budget level of income is what is referred to as the equilibrium of a dynamic model meaning that once we have reached it then so long as none of the exogenous factors in the model changes (and we are treating G as exogenous here) we will stay at it, and it is what is referred to as dynamically stable because the process which we described meant that once we set the process in motion, Y continued to rise until the new balanced budget level of Y had been reached.  That followed, of course, from our assumption that we would finance each period’s deficit by printing new money, (along with our assumption of a horizontal AS curve).

The GBC literature also considered the case of bond financing of the deficits, meaning that in each period in which there was a deficit the government would print new bonds and sell them to the public.  The dynamic consequences of bond financing could be quite different from those of money financing.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.