Friday, June 28, 2019

Modelling International Financial Flow Effects


A number of papers are running stories like this one by Victor Ferreira from the Financial Post, the gist of which is that if the Fed cuts its policy interest rate while the Bank of Canada leaves its unchanged, the Canadian dollar will rise from around 76¢ US, perhaps to 80¢, at which point, the story goes, damage to Canadian exports will force the Bank to cut Canadian interest rates.

It’s by no means an implausible story, but it’s interesting to think about the formal modelling process the Bank would be looking at in deciding what to do.

Wednesday, June 26, 2019

Thinking About Policy Making


Larry Schembri’s discussion  of Canada’s experience with flexible exchange rates in the 1950s includes references to a couple of papers from the 1960s.  One is Robert Mundell’s (1963) Canadian Journal of Economics paper on the effectiveness of fiscal and monetary policy under fixed and flexible exchange rates.  Mundell’s paper is a classic in the literature (which means it’s cited by more people than have actually read it).  Another paper which Schembri cites is a 1964 Journal of Political Economy paper by Rudolf Rhomberg, “A Model of the Canadian Economy Under Fixed and Fluctuating Exchange Rates”
  
The Rhomberg paper was one which I hadn’t run into before, but it presents a nice counterpart to Mundell’s paper.

Tuesday, June 25, 2019

Another Canadian First


As we watch the ongoing sparring between the Trump White House and the Federal Reserve, with the question of whether the President can fire the Chair of the Fed always looming in the background, it’s worth keeping in mind that we (Canada) went through this once ourselves. 

And by This, I mean the whole thing – populist head of government, who was convinced that the head of the central bank was running a tight money policy with the deliberate aim of sabotaging the government’s expansionary economic policy, central bank head sticking to his guns, head of government threatening to fire him, despite its not being clear whether a policy disagreement constituted grounds for dismissal, the whole works.  In our case, it ended with the head of the central bank effectively being fired.

It happened in 1961, and it’s known in Canadian economic history as the Coyne Affair.

Sunday, June 23, 2019

MMT, Functional Finance and the Government Budget Constraint, an overview


When you set aside some of the odder rhetoric, a lot of what some proponents of MMT seem to argue (notice the number of qualifiers there) fits into an older, but still mainstream, Keynesian tradition.  Many analysis regard that model as having failed in the 1970s episode of the Great Inflation, but it’s important to remember that much of the policy analysis being undertaken in that period didn’t include an Aggregate Supply curve in its formal structure.  Early in the General Theory, Keynes identified the notion of the Aggregate Supply curve as a key element of his model, but it had pretty much disappeared from the version which, in the 1960s, became mainstream Keynesianism and was replaced by an exclusive focus on Aggregate Demand.  At least some MMTers seem to have in mind a model with a downward sloping AD curve (probably pretty steep, meaning that AD is not very price elastic) and a Keynesian AS curve consisting of a horizontal segment,  followed, as aggregate income increases along the horizontal axis of the graph, by a positively sloped region which in turn is followed by a vertical region.  At the very least, using that framework, whether or not it’s what the MMTers have in mind, lets us consider the extent to which MMT results can be found in a more mainstream framework.

Saturday, June 22, 2019

MMT and the Theory of the Government Budget Constraint 2


In an earlier post we sketched out a 1970s literature which we argued has a lot in common with Modern Monetary Theory (MMT).  We considered the case where we start at AD/AS equilibrium at an equilibrium level of income where the government’s budget is in balance but where the economy is operating below full employment.   We considered the case where an increase in government spending is used to shift the AD curve to the right, and the resulting deficit is financed by printing money.  In accord with much of the 1970’s literature we assume that the aggregate price level is constant through all of this – that we’re operating on the horizontal segment of the Keynesian AS curve.  They key theoretical point is that the deficit which arises as a result of the fiscal expansion will persist as long as we hold G at the full employment level, and that deficit will have to be financed every period (which really means that G will have to be paid for anew each period) so the money supply will grow continuously even if Y doesn’t change.

Saturday, June 15, 2019

MMT and Inflation


One of the key elements of the MMT argument is the claim that their money finance proposal is not inherently inflationary.  They put this forward in contradiction of the monetarist argument that inflation is a result of increasing the money supply faster than the rate at which GDP is increasing.  (Interestingly, David Andolfatto seems to classify MMT as a version of monetarism.)   As in so many instances, what you take as MMT theory depends on which MMT theorist you’re reading – some seem more open than others to the idea that money-financed spending, shifting the AD curve to the right, might at  some point (i.e. when the AD curve reaches the steeply positively sloped segment of the AS curve) create an inflationary process which would have to be countered by using taxes to pull money out of the economy. 

Thursday, June 13, 2019

MMT and the Theory of the Government Budget Constraint 1


One of the key arguments which MMTers all seem to share is the view that there is no such thing as a government budget constraint, at least, not for a government which can print its own money.  There’s a certain irony to this, since the bit of traditional theory with which MMT seems to have the most in common is the Government Budget Constraint literature of the 1970s, as represented by Blinder and Solow (1973), and extended by Takayama (1980).

The Great Inflation and the End of Bretton Woods


The VoxEU Policy Portal is a site at which a wide range of economists post one- page summaries of their recent research.  The wide range of material which gets posted there, on a wide range of topics, makes it a blog worth keeping an eye on.  Economic historian Michael Bordo recently put up a piece entitled “The imbalances of the Bretton Woods System between 1965 and 1973: US inflation, the elephant in the room” dealing with the factors which led to the end of the Bretton Woods system.

The Bretton Woods system was an agreement negotiated in the late stages of the Second World War to try and set the rules for the post-war international monetary system.  The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund emerged from Bretton Woods.

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

Modern Monetary Theory 4


The basic MMT policy argument seems to start from the assumption that the economy is at AD/AS equilibrium with equilibrium income below the full employment level.  Assume also that, at that equilibrium, the government’s budget is in balance, so the tax revenue, T, generated at that level of aggregate income, is just equal to whatever level of government spending, G, which is being done.  The AD curve can be shifted to the right by increased G, but to hold equilibrium income at the full employment level will require additional G in excess of the additional T that will be generated by the higher aggregate income, so holding equilibrium income at the full employment level will require the government to run a deficit.

Tuesday, June 11, 2019

So What's Out There In The Way of Economics Blogs?


Economics blogging is not what it once was nor, if one is being honest, was it ever what people hoped it would be.  Still, there are a number of blogs it’s worth being aware of.

The best known econ blog is probably Marginal Revolution, run by Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok of George Mason University.  Tyler posts several times daily on anything that interests him, and he has a wide range of interests.  Alex posts less frequently and on a tighter range of topics – intellectual property is one of his particular interests, but recently he’s been posting on a monograph he co-authored that analyzed the time path of a range of prices in the US.  One of MR’s strengths is the links Tyler posts to other sites and news pieces.  He also posts excerpts from, and links to, his regular columns for Bloomberg.  One interesting thing about econblogging is the number of econbloggers who moved to posting on more widely read sites.  Other publishers seem to keep an eye out for people who can write well on economics issues.

Sunday, June 9, 2019

Modern Monetary Theory 3


There’s a lot in at least some versions of MMT which overlaps with old Keynesian theory (and some, but rather less, which overlaps with new Keynesianism).  Let’s see what that overlap is (with the caveat that this is my interpretation of some MMT writings and that there are undoubtedly MMT theorists who would reject it, not to mention those MMT theorists who don’t believe in the validity of formal modelling at all).  I’ll stick key qualifiers in, but keep in mind that this is an outsider’s interpretation.  For links to various MMTers statements of their understanding of the theory, see here.

Thursday, June 6, 2019

MMT, With Japan in the Middle


In the squabbling on the internet over Modern Monetary theory, Japan has emerged, at least in some people’s minds, as the prime test case.  Considering the Japanese economic experience through the 80s into the lost decade of the 90’s, and on into its own version of Quantitative Easing, and its inability to stimulate much in the way of increased output or much in the way of inflation, it’s a country which seems well suited to providing data for testing conventional monetarism, MMT, and probably also the Fiscal Theory of the Price Level.  That would, of course, be a lot easier if there were a well defined body of MMT theory which could be used to develop formal statistical tests.

As it is, we’re forced to rely on websites and newspaper reports: see here, as well as here and here for example.  The New York Times has a longish piece on the Japan question here which we’ll deal with in a later post – I still have some posts on MMT itself to go up.  Be warned that the NYT piece is really just a list of who says Japan is following MMT and who says it isn’t – the most interesting thing in many of the pieces I’ve linked to is when MMTers are cited as saying that no, Japan isn’t implementing MMT.

So Who Should Be Running The Central Bank?


As Stephen Poloz’s term as Governor of the Bank of Canada nears its presumed end, articles have started to appear dealing with the question of who his successor should be.  The betting seems to favour senior Deputy Governor Carolyn Wilkins (and has done for a while) although a  number of other names are also mentioned. 

One issue which comes up occasionally is the background required of the Governor.  Before he went to the the Fed, Ben Bernanke had had a distinguished academic career, and while Janet Yellen was probably best known from the San Francisco Fed, she also had an academic background.  Jerome Powell, on the other hand, spent much of his career in financial markets.  Peter Diamond  was at one point a nominee for a position on the Fed’s board of governors but was opposed (in a decision most economists found hard to believe) on the grounds that his work wasn’t sufficiently money-macro.  Wilkins has a BA from Laurier and a Masters from Western, and has been a career civil servant.

Clearly the Governor of the Bank needs a very specific skill set.  They don’t necessarily have to be a top-level academic researcher, but they do need to be able to consider the recommendations made by the bank’s research staff and to explain decisions made on the basis of that research to politicians and, increasingly these days, to the press and public.  But there’s still a question of the type of analytic skills the governor should have.

Wednesday, June 5, 2019

The Greenspan Put Lives


A Put is a contract which guarantees you the right to sell a particular financial instrument at a set price, within some set time period.  If the market price of the instrument in question stays high, you don’t make use of the put, but if the price of that instrument falls below the pre-set price, you have the option of exercising the put and selling at the set price, which is presumably above the current price and higher than you expect the price to be in the relevant future.

Obviously there has to be someone on the other side of the deal – someone who has guaranteed that they will buy the instrument at the set price if you decide to exercise the put and sell the instrument.  In the standard case, they’re not doing this out of the goodness of their heart: you pay them a fee for the put, so they’re betting that the instrument’s price will stay above the level specified in the put, meaning that they won’t have to buy the instrument from you, so they’ll profit by the amount of the fee you're paying them.

The Greenspan Put is the term used to refer to former Fed Chair Alan Greenspan’s  perceived over-sensitivity to the stock market.  It referred to the perception that the Fed under Greenspan could be counted on to respond to a drop in stock prices by easing monetary policy – basically, Greenspan’s critics argued – that the Fed would print money to prop up the market.

Saturday, June 1, 2019

Interpreting GDP


Japanese GDP grew at an annualized rate of 2.1% in the first quarter of this year, according to the latest estimates, which was much faster than had been expected.  This has not, however, been greeted as a good sign.   As Tim Worstall notes here, the chief reason for the increase in GDP was the fact the fall in imports (M) outweighed that in exports (X), which produced an increase in net exports (X-M) which was large enough to more than cancel out the weak performance of C+I+G. 

This is a result which is almost Trumpian in nature: cut imports and GDP rises.  (Pierre Lemieux has a critical comment on this kind of interpretation here   and Alex Tabarrok has one here.)    If nothing else, it’s a reminder that it’s important to think about what an economic statistic was designed for.  Every introductory macroeconomics textbook makes the point that GDP is not a measure of welfare, however that term might be defined (although very few newsreaders seem to have grasped that point).  That’s also why most proposals for Green GDP measures make no sense – they’re trying to come up with a single sufficient statistic for well-being: one number which we can look at and instantly see whether we, as a society, are better or worse off in some broad sense.