Friday, May 29, 2020

Measuring Inflation in Lockdown


Statistics Canada released the April CPI report on May 20.  The headline sentence was:

“The Consumer Price Index (CPI) fell 0.2% on a year-over-year basis in April, down from a 0.9% gain in March. This was the first year-over-year decline in the CPI since September 2009.”

If you take a look at Chart 1 in the Daily release  you’ll get a pretty dramatic illustration of what StatCan says next: 

“The CPI declined as energy prices fell as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Excluding energy, the CPI rose 1.6%.”

So when you take energy out of the CPI, inflation was 1.6%, with energy in the index it was -0.2%.

Thursday, May 28, 2020

The Bank of Canada's Balance Sheet


One expression which you come across pretty frequently these days refers to the Bank of Canada as having enlarged its balance sheet.  Given what the Bank is, that basically refers to its creating new money, but just saying that is being a bit too bald.  Fortunately, the Bank has an explanation of its balance sheet here, and while the text at that site was written in 2019, the charts are up to date.

The Bank’s balance sheet is a statement of the Bank’s assets and liabilities, where its liabilities are what make up the monetary base.  Since we refer to an increase in its liabilities as “printing money”, it’s interesting to note that back at the end of 2018 the largest single item among its liabilities was “Bank notes in circulation” at about $90 billion, followed by Government of Canada deposits at about $22 billion.  (Strictly speaking that’s liabilities and capital, but I’m going to be sloppy here.)  Deposits held at the Bank by members of Payments Canada came in at $251 Million, as is consistent with Canada’s having eliminated reserve requirements as we traditionally talked about them quite some time ago.  The asset side was dominated by Government of Canada bonds, at $79 billion, with Government of Canada Treasury Bills coming in second at $24 billion and repos at just over $10 billion. Total assets and liabilities at year end, 2018, came (each) to about $116 billion.

Sunday, May 24, 2020

Stephen Poloz's Optimism


Bank of Canada Governor Stephen Poloz has been sounding remarkably sanguine lately, and presumably not just because in a few days the current mess will be Tiff Macklem’s problem.  In comments to the press the other day he was saying that he thought that the pessimism he’d been hearing was overblown, and he was talking about how we’d shut off the economy and used fiscal and monetary policy to put supports under it, going on to say:

“So afterwards, when we turn the economy back on – which we’re just beginning to do – you should see a very rapid return of production,” he said. “If we’ve done a good job, it will have been cushioned well – the shock absorbers have been put in place, and people can pick up where they left off.”

He said that it might take us a year to get back onto the old growth trend line, but he is quite explicitly saying that we will return to the pre-COVID growth trend.

Poloz has said that he tends to think of the current episode as being akin to the effects of a natural disaster.  I’m not entirely convinced of the analogy, since a natural disaster generally involves some destruction of productive capacity, but I’m probably misreading the analogy.  In any event, Poloz is giving a video talk on “Monetary Policy in Unknowable Times” to the University of Alberta on Monday May 25,  with the video to be posted on the Bank’s website.

The rapid bounceback argument does rest heavily on the view that the current situation is best thought of as a major Aggregate Demand event.  Thinking about how to model it, I’d be inclined to set it up as a forced saving variant of the Paradox of Thrift story.

Thursday, May 21, 2020

The Nature of the COVID-19 Economic Downturn


On May 5, the  Macdonald-Laurier Institute’s Philip Cross released the latest run of the MLI’s Leading Economic Indicator, in a post which was headlined  WORSE THAN A RECESSION,CANADA’S ECONOMY IS HEADED TOWARD FREEFALL.  That’s a judgement that it’s hard to dispute.  Further, it’s important to remember that the index is a Leading Economic Indicator, so it’s not just looking at what’s happening today, it’s looking at what today’s occurrences say about what’s likely to happen in the next few weeks.  Overall Philip Cross’s index is pretty accurate, so it’s worth taking seriously.  We can expect to see the Aggregate Demand Curve continuing to shift to the left, even as lockdown eases, in part because people who have been maintaining their spending by running down their assets are going to be running out of those assets.  Government transfers will help cushion that a bit, but we can still expect to see AD remaining soft even after the recovery begins, as people try to restore their depleted stocks of financial assets.  (Cross enumerates the elements of the damage here.)