Friday, May 29, 2020

Measuring Inflation in Lockdown


Statistics Canada released the April CPI report on May 20.  The headline sentence was:

“The Consumer Price Index (CPI) fell 0.2% on a year-over-year basis in April, down from a 0.9% gain in March. This was the first year-over-year decline in the CPI since September 2009.”

If you take a look at Chart 1 in the Daily release  you’ll get a pretty dramatic illustration of what StatCan says next: 

“The CPI declined as energy prices fell as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Excluding energy, the CPI rose 1.6%.”

So when you take energy out of the CPI, inflation was 1.6%, with energy in the index it was -0.2%.


Of course, the drop in gasoline prices had very little to do with COVID-19: it was primarily due to the price war between Russia and Saudi Arabia.  There are other issues in the April CPI which are COVID related though, and William Watson has a discussion of some of them in a Financial Post column here.

The big issue with the April CPI figure is whether it really means anything.  The CPI is supposed to be an index of changes in the cost of buying a basket of goods which, according to Statistics Canada’s survey of household expenditure, is pretty representative of what Canadians do buy.  But what does that mean in a month when we’re not allowed to buy some of the things we’d normally spend on?  Sit-down restaurant meals for example.  When you’re not allowed to buy those, is the CPI in a lockdown month really in any way comparable with the CPI in a month when everything’s open?  And what about the weights various items get in the CPI?  The CPI is a weighted average of relative prices, where the weights are the shares of consumer expenditure which, according to those surveys, Canadians devote to various items.  At the moment the share of sit-down restaurant meals is zero.  After the lockdown’s lifted and restaurants are allowed to open again, a lot of people are going to be hesitant about eating out, so the actual expenditure share of restaurant meals is going to be smaller than usual, and it might well stay smaller for a long time, especially if the public’s reluctance to eat out causes a lot of restaurants to fold, reducing the opportunity to eat out.  How comparable are CPI inflation figures going to be through this period?

Sometimes when there’s a forced zero level of consumption in one period the compilers of price index data insert the price from the previous period into the calculation.  Alternatively it’s been suggested that the price entered for the forced-zero commodity should be a price which would just make the consumer choose zero as their consumption level.  That would be the choke price – the price at which the demand curve for the commodity in question cuts the vertical axis on the (P,Q) diagram so that quantity demanded goes to zero.

Whichever alternative is chosen, it’s fair to say that it won’t be completely satisfactory, partly because it’s not clear what we mean by the cost of living when the levels of some of the commodities which we’d normally consume are constrained to be zero.  So comparisons of the cost of living through the lockdown period, and the calculation of the inflation rate, are going to be matters of dispute for a long time to come.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.