Thursday, May 21, 2020

The Nature of the COVID-19 Economic Downturn


On May 5, the  Macdonald-Laurier Institute’s Philip Cross released the latest run of the MLI’s Leading Economic Indicator, in a post which was headlined  WORSE THAN A RECESSION,CANADA’S ECONOMY IS HEADED TOWARD FREEFALL.  That’s a judgement that it’s hard to dispute.  Further, it’s important to remember that the index is a Leading Economic Indicator, so it’s not just looking at what’s happening today, it’s looking at what today’s occurrences say about what’s likely to happen in the next few weeks.  Overall Philip Cross’s index is pretty accurate, so it’s worth taking seriously.  We can expect to see the Aggregate Demand Curve continuing to shift to the left, even as lockdown eases, in part because people who have been maintaining their spending by running down their assets are going to be running out of those assets.  Government transfers will help cushion that a bit, but we can still expect to see AD remaining soft even after the recovery begins, as people try to restore their depleted stocks of financial assets.  (Cross enumerates the elements of the damage here.)



Then there's a recent talk by Timothy Lane, a Deputy Governor of the Bank of Canada, in which he’s looking ahead to what the state of the economy’s likely to be as we come out of lockdown.  Judging by Lane’s talk, while the Bank hasn’t entirely given up on a V-shaped recovery, it regards a U-shaped one as more probable, and it doesn’t seem to be expecting an L-shaped future.  That appears to be because it regards the current mess as basically a situation of demand deficiency (even though Lane makes the point that the fact of businesses being ordered to shut meant that the downturn wasn’t entirely due to a collapse of demand).  He might be right – the shift from a U-shaped recovery, even with a long, flat bottom to the U, and an L-shaped future in which there’s basically no recovery depends on whether there is an Aggregate Supply shift along with the AD shift. 

Stephen Poloz, it seems, is downright cheerful:

“So afterwards, when we turn the economy back on – which we’re just beginning to do – you should see a very rapid return of production,” he said. “If we’ve done a good job, it will have been cushioned well – the shock absorbers have been put in place, and people can pick up where they left off.”
“After that, yes, we’ll have some legacy to work off, and it could take us a year or more to get back to the [economic] trend line we were on before. I don’t deny this at all. But I’m relatively optimistic ... compared to what the talk is,” he said.”

Note that bit about getting back to the pre-shutdown trend line.  That’s worth a post of its own.

Anyway, a leftward AD shift is going to put downward pressure on prices. On the AS side, we can think in terms of two factors operating.  It’s pretty certain that there’s going to be an upward shift of the AS curve – producers will have to spend on protective equipment and changing the layout of the production area.  If things drag on so that there are significant bankruptcies there will also be a leftward shift of the AS curve.  What happens to the general price level will depend on the balance of the leftward shifts of the AD and the AS curves – if the AD curve shifts more than the AS curve it’s likely that there will be downward pressure on prices, but if the leftward/upward AS shift is large enough the GDP price level could rise even as output fell and unemployment rose.  The Bank sees the AD shift as being the larger of the two.  According to Timothy Lane:

“………we are likely to emerge from the shutdown with both demand and supply weaker than before. The scarring associated with the shutdown could lower productivity, which tends to result in higher inflation. But the Bank’s analysis suggests that the decline in demand stemming in part from weaker business and consumer confidence is likely to have a larger effect. On balance, there is likely to be downward pressure on inflation.”

And then there’s the question of whether there will be an inflationary effect from all of the money that the Bank of Canada is starting to print to finance federal and provincial government spending.  But we’ll leave that for a separate post.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.