Sunday, April 19, 2020

The Macdonald-Laurier Institute’s April Economic Report


The Macdonald-Laurier Institute has just released Philip Cross’s April 2020 Economic Report, which focuses on the hammering the Canadian labour market took in March and on why Philip Cross argues that the unemployment rate is no longer a good indicator of the state of the Canadian labour market.

Cross’s starting point is the fact that, according to the March Labour Force Survey (LFS) unemployment jumped from 5.5% to 7.8%.  Cross makes the point that, while this is the largest ever jump in the unemployment rate in a single month, it’s not even a good measure of what’s happening to measured unemployment, since the LFS is done in a single week, so it doesn’t cover the entire month. 

Beyond the fact that over a million jobs disappeared in March, another 1.3 million people weren’t able to work, despite still being employed and almost a further million reported reduced working hours.  Cross notes that while employment dropped by 5.3%, total hours worked dropped by a full 15.1%.

This drop is obviously going to carry through to GDP, and since GDP is a measure of income generated in the country in a year, it will also carry through to income.  It all works through the aggregate production function.   


Typically, in macro we write the aggregate production function as Y = F(L,K) where L is the Labour input and K is the capital input.  At the macro level we generally assume that the production f unction has constant returns to scale so that on the assumption that factors are paid the value of their marginal product, total income as measured by the value of output produced is fully paid out as factor income. Obviously there are other factors besides labour and capital – electricity and materials being obvious ones – but we generally assume that they’re strictly proportional to the quantities of L and K employed and the total amount of output produced.  The amount of electricity used is assumed to be strictly proportional to the utilization of capital, since idle capital won’t be drawing power.

Strictly speaking the inputs in the aggregate production function aren’t numbers of workers and numbers of pieces of machinery, although using the unemployment rate as the measure of the state of the labour market implicitly assumes that.  In fact, the inputs are labour and capital services.  We can get a better handle on the aggregate labour input by using hours as the L in the production function.  Capital services are more tricky, but one way to get at them is to multiply the capital stock measure – the number of machines – by the capacity utilization rate.

So what Cross is saying is that the fall in the aggregate labour input is best measured not by the number of people who lost their jobs, but by the drop in the number of hours worked.  That will include the hours lost by people who are still employed but not allowed to work because their employers are closed-up but are still technically employing them and also the number of hours lost by the 800,000 or so people who are still employed but have had their hours cut.

In microeconomics, if we cut L and hold K constant we talk about a change in the capital labour ratio – a drop in L with no change in k would actually increase the marginal productivity of labour.  In the case Cross is talking about, though, when hours are cut, it’s not a case of fewer workers each having more capital to work with.  Rather, when aggregate hours are cut, capital is idled for the same period.  That means that L and K are reduced in the same proportion – a 15% reduction in hours will be accompanied by a 15% reduction in the flow of capital services, and since we’re working with a constant returns to scale production function, aggregate output will also fall by 15%.  So, as Cross says, the hit to aggregate income is a lot bigger than the increase in the unemployment rate would suggest.

There’s more to Cross’s analysis, all leading up to his conclusion that:

“The economy will not come “roaring back” as Prime Minister Trudeau predicted in either the short- term or the long-term.”

And it certainly won’t if the shut-down lasts long enough for firms which are hanging on by their fingernails give up and go bankrupt, because in that case not only do the working hours vanish but the capital is effectively removed from the aggregate production function.

There’s been evidence for some time that in the US, the measured unemployment rate had ceased to be a good indicator of the state of the labour market – some people argue that that’s part of the reason US Phillips Curves don’t work any more.  In Canada the measurement problem hasn’t seemed as severe, but in this MLI commentary, Philip Cross makes a pretty good case for why we should start taking some basic measurement issues a lot more seriously.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.