Tuesday, August 20, 2019

Wages and the Business Cycle 3


It’s curious how little guidance our standard models give us about what should happen in labour markets as we come out of a recession.  Employment will increase, of course, but what should happen to the nominal wage?  It’s a bit unfair to be criticizing newspapers for relying on gut feelings, if economic models aren’t giving clear testable hypotheses, at the very least.

Consider the sticky-nominal-wage models.  In those models, nominal wages are sticky downwards, not upwards.  It’s unlikely that nominal wages will fall in a recovery, and there’s a reasonable chance they’ll remain unchanged, if only because there’s still an excess supply of labour so firms don’t have to raise wages to attract labour yet, but as to whether they’ll rise, all we can really say is that if they do, they can’t rise any faster than the price level does, since in the s-n-w models the real wage should be falling , at least through the early stage of the recovery. 

Wages and the Business Cycle 2


The issue of how real and nominal wages should behave over the business cycle at one point prompted a boom in business cycle models.  You have the gut feeling that real wages should be rising in an upswing and falling in a downswing, and there’s a bunch of literature – perhaps the preponderance – which at best doesn’t support the prediction of the sticky-nominal-wage models that real wages should be counter- cyclical: that they should rise in a downturn and fall in a recovery.  The question then was how to build a testable model which might be able to accommodate that view of the world.  One answer seemed to be real business cycle models.

Wages and the Business Cycle 1


One of the trickiest things for newspaper economics journalists, it seems, is to try and sort out what should happen to wages during business cycle ups and downs.  Certainly, a lot of the American press at the moment seem to think that there’s something wrong with the present recovery because wages aren’t rising, or not rising as rapidly as the press had expected.  You do get recognition that wages are rising in certain sectors of the US economy, typically sectors like housing construction where the markets are local and fall into the category that Stock and Watson recently identified as cyclically sensitive (meaning, in essence, producing non-tradeables) but there seems to be a broad feeling in the US press (and to a degree the Canadian, although there seems to be growing awareness that what happens in the US isn’t automatically mirrored in Canada) that for a recovery as long as the present one (albeit a slow recovery), wages should have risen broadly.

Wednesday, August 7, 2019

Currency Matters


The US/China trade and possibly currency wars are rolling along in what seems to be a random walk with upward drift.  Pretty much the only thing you can say about them is that they’re a source of significant uncertainty.  It’s hard to say how far the two sides are prepared to push the matter in practical terms.

The latest move from the Trump administration has been to label China a currency manipulator, meaning that China has broken international rules about using the value of their currency as an instrument for stimulating exports.  This is not an easy claim to evaluate – a while back Donald Trump  was also claiming that the European Central Bank was a currency manipulator.  In some senses it’s a charge which could be levied against pretty much every country, since most places give the impression that they believe that their best hope for stimulating their economies is for someone else to pull them out of recession buy buying more of that the first country wants to export.  And it’s pretty hard to distinguish between policies aimed at currency depreciation and easy money policies aimed at domestic stimulus.

Tuesday, August 6, 2019

Heretics Versus Jerome Powell


Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s attempts to justify the decision to cut the US policy rate do not seem to be garnering rave reviews.  Most of the criticisms in the press seem to come down to the idea that the Fed should have cut rates more if it really wanted to stimulate the economy.  The press seems to have developed a pretty firm faith in the power of monetary policy to drive the economy.

They might have developed that view as a result of hearing economists talk about policy options over the past many years.  Monetary policy has been the focus of the bulk of theoretical writings for quite some time now.  That probably comes out of two observations.

More on the Gold Standard


Ardent supporters of a return to gold are prone to arguing that committing to holding the value of gold in terms of dollars (and therefore the value of the dollar in terms of gold) constant would stabilize the prices of commodities generally or, another way of saying the same thing, hold the real purchasing power of the dollar constant over time.  They’re prone to pointing to the pre-first World War Gold Standard period as evidence that economic stability goes along with backing the currency with gold, and arguing that persistent inflation only became the norm when countries no longer made holding the value of their currencies constant in terms of gold their primary economic objective.
In assessing their claims, it’s worth taking a few minutes to consider how the Gold Standard (which in the pure form which the gold bugs cite only existed for about 50 years) came into being.

Monday, August 5, 2019

Should the Fed say anything at all?


The Wall Street Journal told us recently  that “Jerome Powell’s Off-the-Cuff Approach Leaves Investors on Edge”.

Seems Fed-watchers in the markets can’t figure out what to make of Chairman Jerome Powell’s “effort to bring a more plain-spoken approach to communicating with the public.”.  They were confused by his comments prior to the most recent policy rate decision.  Was he saying that there definitely would be more rate cuts in the future, and then, when he made the July announcement, was he saying after all that there wouldn’t be?

Thursday, August 1, 2019

The Fed’s July 31 Interest Rate Cut


The Fed cut its policy rate on July 31, as most commentators had expected it would do.  The stock markets initially dropped, since the rate cut was smaller than traders had hoped for and because Chairman Powell’s comments didn’t seem to commit the Fed to further cuts.  By August 1 U.S. stocks were up again; according to the Wall Street Journal because traders expect that the Fed will again cut rates again later in the year.  The key question here, of course, is whether the cut will actually do anything to stimulate the economy.  There are pretty good grounds for thinking that the stock market’s response simply reflects the probability of making profit from adjusting portfolio composition rather than from a growing economy.