The Wall Street Journal told us recently that “Jerome Powell’s Off-the-Cuff Approach Leaves Investors on Edge”.
Seems Fed-watchers in the markets can’t figure out what to
make of Chairman Jerome Powell’s “effort to bring a more plain-spoken approach
to communicating with the public.”. They
were confused by his comments prior to the most recent policy rate
decision. Was he saying that there definitely
would be more rate cuts in the future, and then, when he made the July
announcement, was he saying after all that there wouldn’t be?
Markets are also taking more note of what Fed governors are
saying in various different forums:
“Communications hiccups reflect the unfamiliar terrain for Fed leaders navigating a pivot after several years raising rates. In the run-up to last week’s meeting, New York Fed President John Williams cited academic literature urging more aggressive action to support the economy in an environment where the Fed has less room to counteract downturns because rates are historically low.
Mr. Williams is also vice chairman of the rate-setting Federal Open Market Committee, making him a top lieutenant to Mr. Powell. Many investors took his remarks as a sign the Fed was leaning more strongly toward a half-point rate cut. In response, the New York Fed issued an unusual clarification saying the speech hadn’t been intended to deliver a specific signal about near-term policy actions.”
Let’s not overlook the fact that what the markets want to do
is make money, and they want to be able to position themselves to profit from
future Fed actions, which is easier to do if the fed tells them in advance what
it’s going to do. Markets would be
thrilled if the Fed were to commit to a backwards-looking Taylor Rule approach to policy making. What the
Fed is actually saying is that it’s trying to figure out what’s going on with
the neutral rate of interest in the US and adjust to its best estimates of that
so as to keep inflation under control without stifling economic growth,
allowing for the fact that monetary policy sems to be operating with longer
lags these days than it did in the past.
But if Powell were simply to say that, he’d be criticized
for using incomprehensible jargon and for not telling the markets exactly where
the neutral rate was and exactly where it was going to be. So maybe Powell (and the other governors)
should revert to the Fed’s tradition of not saying much about anything. And then financial markets could revert to their traditional approach - reading the auguries in the entrails of chickens.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.