Tuesday, August 6, 2019

More on the Gold Standard


Ardent supporters of a return to gold are prone to arguing that committing to holding the value of gold in terms of dollars (and therefore the value of the dollar in terms of gold) constant would stabilize the prices of commodities generally or, another way of saying the same thing, hold the real purchasing power of the dollar constant over time.  They’re prone to pointing to the pre-first World War Gold Standard period as evidence that economic stability goes along with backing the currency with gold, and arguing that persistent inflation only became the norm when countries no longer made holding the value of their currencies constant in terms of gold their primary economic objective.
In assessing their claims, it’s worth taking a few minutes to consider how the Gold Standard (which in the pure form which the gold bugs cite only existed for about 50 years) came into being.


It’s true that gold and silver were used as measures of value and mediums of exchange long before the Lydians came up with the idea of coins, and the Irish went on using Hacksilver long after other places had adopted coinage.  That seems to have been because pretty much everyone was willing to take gold or silver in exchange for other commodities.  Coins were basically just devices for signaling the quantity of precious metal in disks of particular size.  So long as you trusted the word of whichever local authority had placed their seal on a particular disk of metal, there was no need to go to the bother of testing each individual coin.  

Not every issuer could be trusted, of course, but after a while a fair number of major powers came, independently, to the conclusion that debasing the currency by surreptitiously reducing the gold content was not a good idea.  That resulted in the gold (or silver) content of local coins being stable and reliable, which in turn imparted a degree of local price stability.  People had an idea of how much gold they were prepared to give or take for a certain amount of a particular commodity, and so long as the gold content of the local coinage was held constant, that translated into prices being expressed in terms of number of units of the currency rather than being expressed directly in terms of weights of gold.  You’d still get relative coin-prices changing in response to things like supply shocks, but there would be no intrinsic tendency for the value of coins to drop against all commodities – i.e. no general tendency to inflation.

A side effect of coins being made of precious metal was that the rate of exchange between coins was determined by the relative quantities of gold in each, meaning that so long as the gold content remained constant, so too did the exchange rate.

Over time, of course, peoples started moving away from the use of coin towards the use of paper banknotes.  This happened at different rates in different countries – England was one of the earliest places where people proved willing to accept paper notes as money whereas in Germany, gold coin was still the predominant medium of exchange in daily life right up until the First World War.  The key issue here was the same as that involved in the adoption of coins – if you trusted that the notes represented – were backed by – could easily be exchanged for – a predetermined amount of gold, you’d be willing to take the (much more convenient) notes rather than gold coin.  In pre-Confederation Canada there was no central mint and hence no legal tender local coins, meaning that a range of foreign coins circulated.  There were banknotes which by law had to be convertible into fixed amounts of legal tender specie. 

So now you’ve got paper money, but so long as it is guaranteed convertible into gold at an unchanging rate it amounts to a claim on gold and it’s as good as gold.  The same applies, of course, to every country whose banknotes are trusted in terms of convertibility, so the rate of exchange between paper monies will be equal to the relative quantities of gold they can be converted into.  And when people started using bank accounts and bookkeeping transfers rather than paper currency for payments, the same applied – it all went back to the amount of gold a note was ultimately convertible into.

So you’ve got the international gold standard, under which the exchange rate between currencies was basically an afterthought, so long as everybody was confident that every country held enough gold to meet the likely demand for convertibility.

But the gold standard had its own drawbacks – every country would have to go to the expense of building a secure facility  to store the gold it might possibly need to make good on international conversions (as well as holding gold in its central bank for backing domestic currency conversion).  So a number of countries shifted from holding gold to holding currencies readily convertible into gold.  The one currency which, before the First World War, was absolutely guaranteed to be immediately convertible into gold with no hassle or delay was the British Pound.  And if you were going to back your currency with gold via the pound, it made sense to hold those pounds in the UK – in fact, to hold them in the form of an account at the Bank of England.  So the world shifted from the Gold Standard to what was known as the Gold Exchange Standard and the Bank of England became, as Keynes put it, the conductor of the gold orchestra.  Which, considering how little gold the Bank actually held (relatively speaking) was quite a feat.

Ultimately, though, all of this arose as the endpoint of a process which began with everything being valued, by pretty much everybody, in terms of physical quantities of gold.  The modern Gold Bugs think that we can return to what they see as the relative economic stability of the gold standard era simply by fixing the rate of exchange between the dollar and gold.  That having broken the chain we can, in fact, jump back to its endpoint.  And whether that would work would ultimately depend on whether people still thought of gold as the ultimate measure of value.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.