The Wall Street Journal ran a piece by Paul Kiernan recently
( here but gated ), which starts by saying that one reason
that the Fed is expected to cut interest rates at its next fixing is because
inflation is running persistently below the 2% target. (It’s worth keeping in mind that at the time
2% was picked as the target rate of inflation for many central banks, it wasn’t
because there was careful research saying that 2% was somehow the optimal rate,
it was because the figured that bringing inflation down to around 2% would be a
pretty great achievement.) Setting aside, for the moment, the question of
whether central banks should be trying to get up to 2%, Kiernan raises an
interesting piece of evidence as to why CPI inflation is persistently below 2%.
Monday, July 29, 2019
Friday, July 26, 2019
The State of Macroeconomics
Judy Shelton, one of the names Donald Trump has said he’s
going to put forward for nomination to the Board of Governors of the federal
reserve, is probably the best known of the current crop of gold bugs, but she’s
by no means the only one. For example, SteveForbes of Forbes magazine, who’s run for president a couple of times, recently wrote a column in which he called on Mark Zuckerberg to back Facebook’s Libra cryptocurrency
with gold rather than with the portfolio of safe assets in a range of
currencies which Facebook has been proposing. (He also urged Zuckerberg to
change the name of the cryptocurrency from the Libra to the Mark. Presumably somebody at Facebook nixed calling
it the Zuck.)
Tuesday, July 23, 2019
Dr. Judy Shelton for the Fed
Donald Trump has taken some flack (there’s a certain
redundancy there, isn’t there) for his decision to nominate Judy Shelton to the
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve.
At the same time he nominated Christopher Waller, but since Waller is
the director of research at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, his
nomination is taken as reassuringly orthodox.
Dr. Shelton, on the other hand, has faced severe criticism
on a number of fronts: her Ph.D. is in Business Administration, not Economics; she’s
shifted from being a critic of the Fed’s low interest rate policy before Donald
Trump was elected to calling on the fed to cut rates today, the presumption
being that she was angling for a job with the Trump Administration; and, most
notably, she’s called for a return to the Gold Standard.
Sunday, July 14, 2019
The July 2019 Monetary Policy Report 2: Risks to the Bank of Canada’s Inflation Outlook
As part of the Monetary Policy Report ( pdf here), the Bank of Canada includes a section on risks, in which it includes both
up-side and down-side risks. Up-side risks
are factors which could push the AD curve further to the right than the Bank had
anticipated, and they’re really only
risks if Canada is pretty close to potential output, in which case the output gap could
close unexpectedly and inflation build up faster than the Bank anticipated. So having a good handle on where GDP is
relative to potential, by which, if we’re working with a very Keynesian AS
curve, we mean how close we are to the region of GDP in which the AS curve goes
from being flat to being positively sloped, and equally importantly, how quickly
that positively sloped region steepens into the vertical region of the AS
curve, is extremely important in judging what the Bank should be doing with
interest rates.
Broadly speaking, we can categorize risks under a couple of
headings. There are external risks,
which we can only assess and try to respond to, and there are policy response
risks which relate to how the Canadian economy reacts to the Bank’s policy
actions.
What do we mean by well-anchored inflation expectations?
The recent Globe and Mail commentary by Bill Robson and Jeremy Kronick of the C.D, Howe Institute was in response to
remarks made in the Canadian Senate by Sen Diane Bellemare in which she
recommended that full employment be added to the Bank of Canada’s policy
targets. Sen. Bellemare recentlyresponded in the Globe to Robson and Kronick’s argument. Much of her Globe piece consists of things
like observations that other countries central banks have dual mandates, but as
part of her argument, Sen. Bellemere refers
to:
“………the view expressed on Jan. 4 at the annual meeting of the American Economic Association, by two former chairs of the U.S. Federal Reserve, Janet Yellen and Ben Bernanke, and by the current chair, Jerome Powell. They said that the trade-off between inflation and employment is no longer seen as a problem. Therefore, there is no need to achieve price stability at the expense of employment.”
The idea that the inflation/unemployment trade-off is not a
problem comes out of the fact that unemployment, in both Canada and the US, has
been falling to long term lows without inflation being pushed up above the
central bank targets of 2%. Actually, the
business about the trade-off between inflation and employment longer being seen
as a problem is not quite what was said (you can watch the AEA session here.) What Janet Yellen actually said was
that the Phillips Curve was currently very flat, and Ben Bernanke emphasized
that inflation expectations are currently well anchored.
Thursday, July 11, 2019
The July 2019 Monetary Policy Report 1
The Bank of Canada brought out its July 2019 Monetary Policy
Report recently ( pdf here). The MPR is written for the press and
the general public, so it’s short on technical modelling detail. That’s why we have to dig into it a bit to
get a sense of what lies beneath the Bank’s decision to hold the policy rate
unchanged.
There are a number of interesting points, one of which is
the fact that interest rates really don’t get discussed all that much in the
report – at least, not in the sense of a discussion of the magnitudes of the
effects of changing interest rates. But
that’s something we’ll look at in
another post.
What I want to look at in this post is the way the Bank is
thinking about the effects of a possible escalation of the U.S./China trade war,
how that feeds into its policy decisions, and how the Bank’s thinking seems to
differ from the Fed’s.
Wednesday, July 10, 2019
More fun With the CPI
There are interesting things hidden in the depths of the
monthly CPI report.
Remember that the CPI-Total inflation rate is calculated as a weighted
average of the rates of inflation of individual commodities and that any time
you’re working with a weighted average, the overall average will change if the
distribution of weights across items changes, even if the values of the items
being averaged don’t change. In the case
of the overall (CPI-Total) inflation rate, the weights are the shares of total
consumer expenditure devoted to each commodity, as found in Statistics Canada’s
household expenditure surveys, so rates of inflation for commodities which take up a larger percentage of
the consumer’s expenditure get greater weight in calculating the CPI-Total
inflation rate.
Sunday, July 7, 2019
Thinking about the CPI 1
Statistics Canada recently released the May 2019 figures for the Consumer Price
Index. The 12 month inflation rate
(meaning the percentage increase in the CPI from May 2018 to May 2019) was
2.4%, up from 2% in April 2019 (i.e. the increase in April 2019 relative to
April 2018). Putting it that way makes
it sound as if all prices rose at the same general rate. In fact there was considerable variation
among commodities.
For example, fresh vegetables rose 16.7% over the year,
contributing to a rise in food prices overall of 3.4% while gasoline fell 3.7%. The StatCan report gives a list of the main
upward and downward contributors to the 12 month increase.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)