Tuesday, July 23, 2019

Dr. Judy Shelton for the Fed


Donald Trump has taken some flack (there’s a certain redundancy there, isn’t there) for his decision to nominate Judy Shelton to the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve.  At the same time he nominated Christopher Waller, but since Waller is the director of research at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, his nomination is taken as reassuringly orthodox.

Dr. Shelton, on the other hand, has faced severe criticism on a number of fronts: her Ph.D. is in Business Administration, not Economics; she’s shifted from being a critic of the Fed’s low interest rate policy before Donald Trump was elected to calling on the fed to cut rates today, the presumption being that she was angling for a job with the Trump Administration; and, most notably, she’s called for a return to the Gold Standard.


There are always a certain number of gold bugs around – people who think that a return to gold would ensure price, and general economic, stability.  Some of them are more cogent than others – James Grant, who’s always worth reading if only because he writes well, had a Wall Street Journal column in favour of a return to gold earlier in July (paywalled).  There tends to be a certain amount of wishful thinking involved: being on gold did not eliminate business cycles, and the failure of France and the US to play by the rules of the gold standard game in the 1930s is regarded as one of the causes of the Great Depression.  The history of the Gold Standard was discussed in the 1982 report of the US Gold Commission, an event so underwhelming that nobody’s even bothered to produce a Wikipedia page for it. 

(The Commission’s Executive Director was Anna Schwartz, Milton Friedman’s co-author on the Monetary History of the United States, and she did write a brief summary of its establishment and conclusions, free pdf version here.  Its congressional sponsors were JesseHelms and Ron Paul, the latter of whom was pretty representative of a group of thinkers who argue that mistaken monetary policy is the source of virtually all economic instability.  Ron Paul was a member of the Commission – his pro-gold minority report is available from the Mises Institute, here.)

Judy Shelton comes across as believing that anchoring the US dollar to gold would prevent the Fed from manipulating the purchasing power of the dollar for other policy purposes – she, like the Austrian Theorists at the Mises Institute, are of the view that the dollar is a measure of value and that a measure is only useful if it can be counted on the be the same at all times.  A kilo is of no use as a measure of weight if the amount of weight it represents changes over time.  They’re in respectable company on this general point – Aristotle held the same view.

The question is how you do this.  The Kilo is defined in terms of certain physical constants.  The idea of the Gold Standard is to tie the dollar to a certain economic constants, which is what a certain quantity of gold is presumed to be.  The analogy isn’t a very good one, however.  The gold standard works by declaring that a dollar is equivalent to a certain quantity of gold – the 1900 US Gold Standard Act defined the dollar as being equal to 23.22 grains of pure gold – the pound sterling was defined as 113 grains of pure gold.  The dollar was fixed to gold in the sense that the US government committed to buying or selling gold at 23.22 grains to the dollar – to holding the price of 23.22 grains of pure gold at $1.00.  It did this the way it holds the price of any commodity fixed – by buying when there was an excess supply and selling when there was excess demand.  Effectively, then, the government had to commit to adjusting the money supply to whatever degree was necessary to hold the price of 23.33 grains of pure gold constant at $1.00.  That, in turn, meant that the primary mandate of monetary policy was to adjust the money supply to whatever degree was necessary to hold the price of gold unchanged, regardless of the impact that might have on other parts of the economy.

The trouble is, as many people have pointed out recently, is that the only thing this stabilizes is the price of gold.  There’s a leap of faith involved in assuming that 23.22 grains of pure gold will have a stable command over other commodities, especially since people have become accustomed to thinking of gold as a speculative investment good rather than as a measure of value.  Judy Shelton has invoked the name of RobertMundell but Mundell, while favouring the development of some kind of international money, didn’t think a return to gold made sense and certainly didn’t think it would be a good idea for the US to go back to gold on its own.  (One of his arguments was, do you really want to base your monetary system on a commodity one of whose chief sources was Russia?)

On the other hand if we presume that Judy Shelton’s overriding target for monetary policy is price stability, she’s in pretty good company, even though most others in that group would firmly reject a return to gold as a way of accomplishing stability.  John Cochrane, for example has argued that:
“Gold-standard advocates offer a cogent critique of current monetary policy, but a return to gold is unfeasible. A stable CPI, immune from both inflation and deflation, backed by the same fiscal commitments that underlay gold, is worth taking seriously.”

Even this version has it critics, though.  In the comments on Cochrane’s post, George Selgin, who blogs on monetary economics at Alt-M  and who is an advocate of free banking asks: What about adverse supply shocks……. Is it a good idea for the fed to shrink M to keep P from rising in response to those?  That’s an issue the Bank of Canada tackled in its July Monetary Policy Report, except that the Bank was arguing that expanding the money supply in an attempt to reduce unemployment in the face of an adverse supply shock might well simply result in inflation.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.