Tuesday, April 14, 2020

COVID-19 And Demand and Supply Side Effects

John Palmer has a post at his EclectEcon blog on how he's handling the COVID-19 situation.  Down towards the bottom he remarks:
 And I further resent the use of the term "stimulus". There's nothing to stimulate! This is a major supply-side shock to the economy, and until people can start producing goods, and especially services, we can't help but experience a major drop in GDP.
The whole issue of whether the current shock is a supply-side or demand-side episode informs not just what's happening right now, but it also plays into what the recovery will look like when restrictions are eventually eased.  Whether, as John Cochrane puts it in this Grumpy Economist blog post we're going to have a V- shaped, a U-shaped or an L-shaped recovery.

A V-shaped recovery would mean a deep downturn while restrictions are in place, followed by a large and rapid recovery as soon as they're lifted.  That's what a lot of the early commentators said would happen, and while it's not impossible, it's looking increasingly unlikely.


For this to be a V-shaped episode the whole thing would have to be an Aggregate Demand shock, and a short-lived one at that.  Yes a lot of people are losing their incomes,  but a lot of other people still have income coming in but aren't allowed to spend it.  The mandated shutdown of a lot of places of business is a supply side factor, but productive capacity hasn't been reduced, it's just been taken off line temporarily.  The idea is that as soon as the restrictions are lifted, the people who have still been receiving income will go out and do a mess of catch-up spending, bolstered by government spending as necessary, and unemployed workers will be called back to work, and put to work on idled capital so that the aggregate supply rises as the demand does.  There's a shift of the Aggregate Demand curve both during the downturn and during the recovery, but no fundamental shifting of the Aggregate supply curve.

The assumption of no AS shift was embodied in all of those assertions that the food supply chain, for example, was solid and secure.  The commentators making those assertions seem almost to have visualized supply chains as being completely automated, whereas in fact each link in the supply chain is a collection of firms, using capital and applying labour to do their bit in the entire process.  As the New York Times has recently discovered, the fact that there's labour involved in those links makes them as vulnerable as any other part of the economy which involves labour.  We can expect to see a bit of an upward shift of the AS curve as firms in essential sectors respond to workers' concerns, although that probably won't be a major effect in the short run.

What matters more is how long the shutdown drags on.  If it's over quickly we'll probably see that V-shaped pattern.  If it drags on a bit longer the re-start will take longer and we'll see a U-shaped recession, possibly with a long bottom to the U.  But if we stay shut down for anything close to the period some public health people were talking about, or for the indefinite period it'll take before we get a vaccine in place, the Aggregate Supply side effects will come to dominate and we'll wind up with an L-shaped economy. 

The key issue here is going to be how long small business can hang on with no revenue coming in.  Most small businesses don't have the cash reserves to keep going too long and at some point are going to go bankrupt.  When that happens their capital stock is effectively taken out of the economy, even if it's physically still in existence, and we move into a depression equilibrium. 

Think about a restaurant.  In the short run the kitchen equipment's still there, even if it's not being used, and the staff could be brought back to work relatively easily if demand recovered.  But if the existing restaurant closes permanently, then even if the physical capital is still there it won'e be used until someone else gets the finance to acquire it.  And that will require, first, that someone decide it's worth the risk of going into debt to acquire the business and, second, that someone else decides that it's worth the risk of lending them that finance.

It's when we get into that last situation that the AS effects come to dominate.  And if we do reach that stage we're effectively stuck in a depression equilibrium - we're on the flat portion of the L.  So the crucial thing in determining the shape of the recovery is the duration of the enforced shutdown, and one crucial consideration is how long a lot of small firms are willing to go on accumulating debt, even with government assistance, before the burden gets too heavy.





No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.