Wednesday, June 5, 2019

The Greenspan Put Lives


A Put is a contract which guarantees you the right to sell a particular financial instrument at a set price, within some set time period.  If the market price of the instrument in question stays high, you don’t make use of the put, but if the price of that instrument falls below the pre-set price, you have the option of exercising the put and selling at the set price, which is presumably above the current price and higher than you expect the price to be in the relevant future.

Obviously there has to be someone on the other side of the deal – someone who has guaranteed that they will buy the instrument at the set price if you decide to exercise the put and sell the instrument.  In the standard case, they’re not doing this out of the goodness of their heart: you pay them a fee for the put, so they’re betting that the instrument’s price will stay above the level specified in the put, meaning that they won’t have to buy the instrument from you, so they’ll profit by the amount of the fee you're paying them.

The Greenspan Put is the term used to refer to former Fed Chair Alan Greenspan’s  perceived over-sensitivity to the stock market.  It referred to the perception that the Fed under Greenspan could be counted on to respond to a drop in stock prices by easing monetary policy – basically, Greenspan’s critics argued – that the Fed would print money to prop up the market.


Whether that criticism was justified or not, the perception that something like it is a regular part of Fed policy seems to be widespread in the stock market.  As the New York Times put it on June 3, 2019: “Wall Street Pins Its Hopes on Fed Rate Cuts”

The Times piece goes on to say:
“Traders are betting the Fed will bail them out again. If they’re wrong, things could get ugly.   ………..   This stark change in expectations coincides with a deterioration in the outlook for growth, after a month of worsening trade relations and slumping stock markets.   …….  The stakes are high. Throughout the decade-long bull market, stock investors have repeatedly taken their cue from the Fed’s interest rate decisions, which have infused fresh life into stocks.”

Then in the June 4 Times  we have:  “Stocks Jump as Fed’s Powell Suggests Rates Could Come Down”and 
"Mr. Powell’s remarks sparked a rally on Wall Street. Equity markets — which had risen ahead of the remarks — piled up the gains in the hours after his statement. The S&P 500 rose 2.1 percent, its second-best daily gain of the year. The S&P is up 11.8 percent this year.    ………………………  The rebound in stock markets coaxed some investors out of the safety of government bonds, pushing prices down and yields — which move in the opposite direction — up."

Although as the June 5 NY Times DealBook section warns,  “A Rate Cut Isn’t a Done Deal”.

The key question here is whether the stock market is really focused on the prospects for the real economy, or whether we’re really looking at portfolio adjustments.  Are we hearing from traders who are afraid that if interest rates go up, they will lose on the drop in stock prices which will follow as investors shift into bonds?  When the real economy’s growing very slowly, profit is made off volatility rather than growth, and in particular off anticipating (correctly) the way the market is going to move in the short run.  That means there may be a return to be made from putting pressure on the Fed to move interest rates one way or the other. 

That’s why Central Bankers have to be quite clear as to what their policy target is.  As Bill Robson of the C.D. Howe Institute said in the Globe and Mail recently, responding to suggestions that the Bank of Canada should be targeting more than just the inflation rate, the Bank of Canada Act doesn’t need tweaking.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.