Wednesday, June 12, 2019

Modern Monetary Theory 4


The basic MMT policy argument seems to start from the assumption that the economy is at AD/AS equilibrium with equilibrium income below the full employment level.  Assume also that, at that equilibrium, the government’s budget is in balance, so the tax revenue, T, generated at that level of aggregate income, is just equal to whatever level of government spending, G, which is being done.  The AD curve can be shifted to the right by increased G, but to hold equilibrium income at the full employment level will require additional G in excess of the additional T that will be generated by the higher aggregate income, so holding equilibrium income at the full employment level will require the government to run a deficit.


In the MMT model, this deficit will be money financed.  Indeed, based on their argument about what happens to the monetary base when the fiscal authority increases its spending, some of them seem to argue that all increases in G are necessarily accompanied by – financed by – increases in the money supply.  This overlooks the question of how the fiscal authority lays its hands on the money to spend in the first place, but set that aside for the moment.

A key criticism which has been directed at the MMT types is that while they reject the monetarist explanation of inflation, they lack a formal theory of inflation of their own.  Their writings seem to invoke two theories of inflation: a demand-pull one and a cost-push one.

Some MMT writings I’ve seen invoke a pretty standard demand-pull theory, at least in the sense that they say that, if in the process of moving the economy to full employment inflation is observed to be building up, the appropriate policy response would be to raise taxes (i.e. raise the tax rate) to pull money out of the economy.  Their terminology implies that they see changes in the money supply as the driving force behind changes in real economic activity.  Think MV=PY with constant Velocity, Y below its full employment level and the assumption that as long as Y is below full employment increases in M translate into increases in Y, not increases in P.  Since, in their policy model, increases in G are accompanied by increases in M and are the mechanism by which the increases in M are created and injected into the economy, this is internally consistent. So it is logically consistent that they see increases in Taxes as pulling money out of the economy and this as shifting the AD curve back to the left. 

The other explanation for inflation which some MMTers have cited is one which was very widely held, especially among British economists, in the 1950s and 60s.  Ultimately it was a cost-push argument, but underlying it was the notion that various groups, including labour, competed for shares of total aggregate income by raising the price they charged for the factor of production which they supplied.  This view focused primarily on labour as the driving factor behind inflation, as some groups tried to increase their share of aggregate income by demanding higher wages and other groups felt the need to protect their relative income position by demanding wage increases of their own.  In the AD/AS diagram, this argument has inflation being driven by ongoing upward shifts of the AS curve, and in the decades in which it was in vogue, the preferred anti-inflation policy of its proponents involved various types of income policies including wage and price controls.  This type of inflation differs from the demand-pull AD/AS version since it can arise even in the face of involuntary unemployment, whereas demand-pull inflation won’t set in until the AD curve has been shifted far enough to the right.

Many of the MMTers who adopt the cost-push view of inflation seem to prefer a policy option which involves a job guarantee.  An increase in tax rates will pull money out of the economy and, by shifting the AD curve to the left, will create unemployment.  Those people who are put out of work by this process will be given jobs by the government, and paid a wage below the one which they were trying to extract from the competition for income shares which set off the cost-push process.  The wage associated with the job guarantee would, by definition, not be subject part of the competition for relative position, so the threat of losing a private sector job and being moved into a worse-paying public sector job would impose a discipline on labour, and this mechanism would halt any tendency for the AS curve to shift upward.  Thus the wage associated with the job guarantee would also anchor the price level.

Recently, there seems to have been a shift among MMTers away from the demand-pull argument.  You’ll see claims to the effect that demand-pull inflation is not a factor in the American economy, since it hasn’t been seen for decades.  There are a couple of problems with this, deriving from the horizon they seem to be taking in their scan of economic history.  The period they tend to refer to is basically since the 1980s, meaning that they’re looking at the period in which central banks had recovered their independence and focused their attention on using monetary policy to control (demand-pull) inflation.  It seems, then, that MMTers are using a period in which conventional anti-inflationary money policy was successful to argue that we don’t need anti-inflationary money policies.  In addition, they don’t seem to be looking at the period of the 60s and 70s, especially in the US.  That was a period in which central banks tended to be very accommodating to the fiscal authorities, basically printing money to fund government spending.  In the US, Lyndon Johnson, aware that Congress would not give him the taxes needed to fund both the Vietnam War and the Great Society social programs, put pressure on the Fed to print the money he needed, and the Fed proved pretty accommodating.

That’s how the American inflation of the 70s and 80s got going, but what about the Canadian inflation – Canada wasn’t in Vietnam, after all.  The Canadian inflation was a consequence of our having adopted a fixed exchange rate policy shortly before (in the 1950s we let the Canadian dollar float for a number of years).  Under the Breton Woods agreement, countries were supposed to peg their currencies to the US dollar.  This was a policy which didn’t anticipate the Americans inflating the way they did – the increased supply of US dollars, which spilled from the US domestic market into the international market, tended to push the US dollar down on foreign exchange markets, which, looked at from the other side, meant that the Canadian dollar was rising relative to the US dollar.  In order to hold our exchange rate constant it was necessary for the Bank of Canada to print large quantities of new Canadian dollars and use them to buy US dollars, supporting the price of the US dollar in Canadian dollar terms.  Since those newly printed Canadian dollars stayed in, and were spent in Canada, we basically imported the US inflation, and did it by increasing our own money supply.

In addition to a shift away from the demand-pull argument by some MMTers, there’s also been a shift in the cost-push argument.  Increasingly we’re seeing MMTers talking about how large corporations can use their market power to drive their prices up at will.  The rhetoric is turning Galbraithian, which suggests that we can expect to see these MMT theorists turn more and more towards the sort of policies which John Kenneth Galbraith supported: money financed expansions in government spending combined with wage and price controls to restrain any inflationary pressures.  Given the reference to large firms in the MMT sources, we can probably expect to see arguments along the lines which Galbraith made in his Theory of Price Control and elsewhere, to the effect that controls only need be impose don the largest firms, those with the greatest market power.  Restrict their ability to pass cost increases through to their customers and they would have a powerful incentive to resist cost increases from their suppliers, including labour. 

So, judging from some of their recent arguments, don’t be surprised if the MMTers wind up reinventing the Galbraithian wheel.  

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.