Tuesday, May 14, 2019

Measuring Labour Market Tightness

Apropos of the release of the April Canadian Labour Force Survey, there was an interesting piece in the New York Times  a little while ago on the question of why wages have been so sluggish in their response to falling unemployment.  One argument that’s made in the piece is that the unemployment rate is the wrong indicator of labour market tightness – that we should be looking at the non-employment rate among prime age individuals.  Non-employment includes both the registered unemployed and those people who have dropped out of the labour force – discouraged workers who would be willing to work but have stopped looking for work, in the sense required to have them counted as being in the labour force.  In terms of the official measures, they show up in the form of a decline in the labour force participation rate.  The argument’s been made that the reason wage growth has been sluggish is that improved employment opportunities have drawn discouraged workers back into the labour force, shifting the labour supply curve to the right and restraining the wage growth that might otherwise accompany an outward shift of the labour demand curve.
The Times piece cites Adam Ozimek: some of his arguments can be found on a Moody's site.

It’s not a good idea to assume that what happens in Canada automatically mirrors the US experience, especially as far as the labour market is concerned, so it would be interesting to replicate some of the econometrics which has been done on US data, using Canadian data, and see whether the same story holds here.  Since the Bank of Canada is concerned with whether keeping the rate of interest low is letting inflationary pressures build up, and since labour market tightness is one of the key elements in the inflationary process (along with the degree of capacity utilization), having a sense of how closely the non-employment rate explains inflation as compared with the explanatory power of the unemployment rate would be a useful element in trying to get a handle on the way the Bank sees the state of the economy.

Update:  Greg Mankiw argues that the Fed should be paying more attention to wage trends than to the unemployment rate.  In his post, Mankiw links to a Wall Street Journal op-ed by Neel Kashkari, President of the Minneapolis Fed. In that piece, Kashkari says:

"The unemployment rate lately has falsely signaled that maximum employment was near, even though millions more jobless people still wanted to work. In 2015 Federal Open Market Committee participants estimated that unemployment couldn’t go below 5.1% without triggering inflation. The rate is now 3.6%, which means 2.4 million more Americans have found work, yet inflation remains low.
.................................................................
Remarkably, more than 70% of people who got jobs in April indicated the previous month that they weren’t looking for work."
That last line means that there was significant movement (in the US) into employment by people who had been counted as out of the labour force rather than having been counted as unemployed.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.