Sunday, May 12, 2019

A Note On The April 2019 Labour Force Survey

The April 2019 Labour Force Survey results made a lot of headlines because of the size of the increase in employment, but for purposes of judging where we are relative to potential output, and therefore what the Bank of Canada is likely to be doing, the details are what matter .



While the overall unemployment rate is a bit below where it was just before the 2008 economic downturn, the overall employment rate is still below its pre-recession level.  On the other hand, the employment rate for the 25 to 54 group is back above its pre-shock level and the employment rate for the 55 to 64 year group is well above where it was when the shock hit – it’s been on an upward trend for a considerable number of years, and while it dipped a bit at the time of the shock, it had recovered to its pre-shock level within about a year.  The biggest hit to the employment rate was in the 15 to 24 year age group, and while that rate’s back up, it’s still below its immediate pre-shock level.

The participation rate for the 15 to 24 year age group was the only one of the broadly defined participation rates to have dropped significantly at the time of the shock and while it’s up in the latest survey, it’s still visibly below its pre-shock level. 

There are obviously lots of ways we can slice the data (the summary report can be found here and the detailed numbers can be downloaded here in a form which can be manipulated and graphed in Excel, something which is generally worth doing).  We can look at male and female rates separately (the figures I’ve looked at were for both sexes combined) and we can subdivide by things like education level and type of work – the gig economy has put workers at a serious disadvantage, for example. Plus regional differences always get a fair bit of play in the media.

At a policy level, the key question is whether there is a way of subsetting, or looking at, the data which gives us a consistent picture of the output gap – of where we are relative to potential output and of how inflationary pressures are likely to be building up.  That’s what is needed for policy making purposes: a way of looking at the data which does a reasonably job of summarizing what’s going on with regards to the factors which, for example, the Bank of Canada thinks play into the location of the neutral rate of interest.

This means that we're hoping that we can find econometrically stable relationships among the key variables.  If we’re trying to estimate some variant on the Phillips Curve, for example, we're hoping to find an equation whose coefficients don't change much over time, so that we're not reduced to having to say, much of the time, that there is a relationship but it's shifted in some unexpected way since the last time we looked at it.  Absent that, we’re likely to spend our time looking backwards, when policy makers need to be able to look forwards.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.