Wednesday, May 22, 2019

The New York Times on the Fed’s Puzzle


The New York Times ran a piece on May 21 dealing, ultimately, with the Fed’s problem figuring out where the neutral rate of interest is these days, although that term isn’t used in the article itself.  The primary focus of the article is on the ongoing puzzle of the relation between inflation and indicators of labour market tightness.  The framing device is the story of a restaurateur in North Carolina whose business is booming and who is hiring but who doesn’t want to risk passing higher wage rates on her customers in the form of higher prices, because no-one else in the industry is raising their prices.  


According to the article:
‘The stable pricing is sustainable partly because the Roys have gotten less picky about whom they hire. By looking at applicants with limited experience and even criminal records, they can find workers at wages that shrink — but don’t kill — their profit margins.
“It used to be that you’d look at résumés, and some things were an automatic disqualifier,” Ms. Roy said. “Now there’s really no disqualifier. Anyone who comes in, we’ll interview them.”’
And further:
‘Across the United States, a similar cocktail seems to be keeping inflation at bay: Employers are reluctant to charge more, unsure how consumers will react, and they’ve found an untapped supply of workers. It’s partly great news. More Americans are getting jobs than policymakers once thought possible, and wages and prices aren’t spinning out of control the way history would predict.’

Basically, it appears that the labour supply curve is much more elastic than the US unemployment rate would seem to indicate, suggesting that there’s a lot of movement into jobs from the category “not in the labour force” than has tended to be the case in past recoveries.  This would seem to be a good thing from the perspective of the US economy as a whole since it means that people who might previously have been excluded from the labour market are being drawn into it, without serious inflationary pressure building up and eating into the standard of living of people who are already employed, but it’s a problem for the Fed because it throws its estimates of the size of the output gap out of kilter. 

The article invokes two themes which are pretty common in articles like this one.  The first is the difficulty that the fed is having pushing inflation up to 2%.I (incidentally, the piece also makes a common mistake when it says that inflation rose 1.6% in the year ending in March.  Prices rose 1.6%, inflation was 1.6%.  And the Fed does not have a 2% target for increases in inflation, it has a 2% target for the level of inflation. The Fed is not aiming to have the rate at which prices are increasing increase by 2% - or 2 percentage points – a year.)  It, and a lot of analysts, simply take for granted that having prices rising 2% a year is somehow good for the economy and that falling short of that rate is a problem.  It’s worth remembering that 2%  was the rate the fed hoped to bring inflation down to, at a time when that looked like a goal that would take decades to achieve. 

The second theme is the problem which low interest rates could cause for future monetary policy.  To a large degree that comes down to not being sure where the elasticity of interest sensitive elements of aggregate demand is under present circumstances.

Both of these themes are amenable to empirical research, and in both cases we have long enough time series data since the 2008 recession to allow us to test for structural change in the relation between inflation and various indicators of labour market tightness,   and in the responsiveness of consumption and investment, individually, to the level of interest rates.  As a rule of thumb, the more variation there is in your explanatory variables, the more informative your econometric results are likely to be.

And since it’s never safe to assume that American results automatically carry over to the Canadian case, running those equations on Canadian data (which is something you can be pretty sure the Bank of Canada is doing) would add a lot to our understanding of where the Canadian neutral rate is.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.