John Cochrane, formerly of the University of Chicago and now
of the Hoover Institution, wrote a blog post, a little while ago, giving his take on Modern Monetary
Theory (MMT). It had the potential to be
very interesting, considering that MMT and Cochrane’s own Fiscal Theory of thePrice Level (FTPL) start from the proposition that state-issued money has value
only because the state will accept it in payment of taxes.
Unfortunately, there’s not a lot of analytical content in
Cochrane’s post. Rather, he focuses on MMT’s
place in what he terms the sociology of science. His remarks are justified, but there’s a bit
of a sense that he’s shooting fish in a barrel. He makes the point, which many have made, that
most of the writings of the MMT types seem to be on blogs and in columns of
various types, and not in academic journals. He’s done a bit of a lit search
and found a few articles, in places like the Journal of Post Keynesian
Economics, and the Journal of Economic Issues, which are, as he notes,
low-ranked journals. His search seems to
have missed some articles which it should have picked up, but these are also in
places like JPKE. He’s critical of the
failure of the MMT types to publish in places like the American Economic
Review, although you have to wonder whether an MMT piece would make it past AER
refereeing. He’s also critical of central
bankers for relying on what are essentially old Keynesian ISLM models for
policy purposes, arguing that those models haven’t been seen in major journals
in years. He puts a lot of weight on
publication in top ranked journals, although to his credit he does recognize
that a lot of silly stuff has been published in those top-ranked places.
MMT theory is an offshoot of Post-Keynesian Economics, which
to most economists is not an informative statement and, if they’re familiar
with PKE, is not a recommendation. It’s
hard enough to define PKE, at least in a manner which is meaningful to
outsiders, and as soon as you do you have to start distinguishing between the
American and British Post-Keynesians. Post-Keynesianism strikes outsiders as a
broad term encompassing a collection of sects, whose members seem more focused
on wiping out heretics than on spreading the word to the rest of the
world. The one thing which they all seem
to have in common, besides rejecting each others’ theories, is a belief that
their particular sect are the true heirs of the Keynesian revolution.
MMT theorists set themselves apart by their tendency to
reject formal modelling, a stance which makes it particularly difficult to understand
what their model actually is, and makes it practically impossible to set up an
empirically testable version. MMT
theorists regard this as a feature, not a bug.
But while there’s a legitimate case to be made that many more mainstream
economists seem to prioritize mathematical elegance over realism, it remains
true that formalizing a model is a process which forces you to think your
assumptions through carefully.
MMT also suffers, in mainstream eyes, from the fact that
it’s been adopted so whole-heartedly by certain left-wing American
politicians. Not that they have any
better notion of MMT’s theoretical basis than the rest of us do – the appeal to
most of them is clearly the notion that government can spend as much as it
wants, printing money to do so, without causing inflation. To the rest of us, any theory which can be
taken as supporting unlimited spending has to be suspect. We'll look at the reasons why (and indeed, whether this is a fair characterization of MMT) in a later post.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.