Wednesday, May 15, 2019

The Stock Market and the Economy

The main thrust of the May 7 FP piece by David Rosenberg which was referred to in a previous post was that “..... the stock market has no statistically significant relationship with the underlying economy…….”.  It’s an argument which has been made many times over many years, but it carries particular freight in the era of Quantitative Easing by the Fed.  One of the channels through which QE was supposed to have an effect is referred to as the Portfolio Balance Channel – while Rosenberg takes a slightly different tack than I’m going to here, his article reminds us that we need to think of a portfolio as containing stocks, bonds and cash, and raises the question of the extent to which central bankers’ policy decisions should incorporate responses to stock market behaviour.

This isn’t a new question.  In the run-up to the 1929 crash the (still relatively new) Fed board debated whether monetary policy should respond to the on-going run-up in the market, and more recently the Fed is said to have responded to the stock market 1987 crash by running monetary policy which effectively set the stage for later bubbles.  Austrian School economists (see the Coordination Problem blog, for example) argue that badly designed monetary policy lies behind most financial bubbles – the central bank runs too easy a monetary regimen for too long then, when it realizes its mistake, tightens up too sharply, causing the bubble to burst and triggering a recession.  In the case of post-2008 Fed policy, QE, which resulted in a significant increase in the size of the monetary base, involved the fed making very large scale purchases of US government debt on the open market (the Fed has historically been banned from buying government bonds directly from the Treasury, so it has to conduct open market operations through the auction market).  This was something it was quite capable of doing because it could basically bid up the price of the debt it was buying to whatever level was necessary to persuade its holders to sell.  The result was that groups which had been holding the debt were now holding more cash than they had planned, and started looking for income-generating assets to put it in.  With interest rates at historically low levels, they put a higher proportion than would otherwise have been the case in the stock market, which tended to drive stock prices up.



The flip side of this is that whenever it looks as if central banks might be planning to raise interest rates, stock markets get edgy: a rise in interest rates would pull risk-averse money out of the stock market, which would cause stock prices to fall.  In fact, if the probability of a rate increase looks high, some money will be moved into cash before the policy is actually implemented, causing downward pressure on stock prices.  Arguably, the Fed by changing the mix of assets available on the open market, prompted large scale portfolio rebalancing, and a return to more traditional rates of interest would similarly have portfolio effects.

We tend to talk about stock prices as reflecting expectations about long run profit streams, but it’s important to remember that most trading just involves changes of ownership of existing shares.  Maynard Keynes complained that the short term focus of most stock trading in the 1930s meant that anyone who was trying to invest for the long run was going to be at a significant disadvantage in the market.  And interestingly enough, it wasn’t long after the first modern stock exchange was established in Amsterdam in 1602 that complaints started to emerge that some individuals were using it for short term returns, not for long term investing.

Criticisms of central bank policies which might cause stock prices to fall tend to be a lot louder than criticisms of policies which cause them to rise, so the Austrians’ critique has force.  In the present case, QE was necessary to prevent financial markets from freezing up, but it did result in a pretty massive increase in liquidity, which was bound to produce portfolio responses.  Another reason to be wary about claims that the stock market is a good indicator of the health of the real economy.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.