Let’s look at one of the points Rosenberg’ makes about investment.
In thinking about Rosenberg’s comments, it’s important to remember what QE was intended to do and to distinguish that from what seems to have come to be expected of it ( There's a pdf of an article in which Alan Blinder gives a historical overview here). QE was basically intended to pump massive amounts of liquidity into the US banking system to prevent the whole thing from freezing up in the wake of the Lehman Bro’s. collapse. At the same time the Fed slashed its policy interest rates (there’s a nice graph of the Federal Funds Rate in the Blinder piece). If we think of what followed in the wake of the financial crash as a tremendous increase in the liquidity preference of the financial system, the Fed was aiming to accommodate that increase so that financial institutions wouldn’t try to increase their liquidity by selling assets they already held and refusing to acquire others. So the original idea was to prevent another Great Depression arising from, and magnifying, a crash of the financial system.
Recently, focus has been on the effects of the rate of interest on the real economy. The expectation has been that the low interest rates which have been part of all central banks’ policies should have stimulated real investment spending, and produced an upward multiplier effect, as in the model of the intro macro textbooks. As Rosenberg argues, this does not seem to have happened: “…… it does say something about ex ante rate of return assumptions on invested capital when capex growth slows down at a time when the underlying cost of capital is so low……..”. In terms of that intro macro model, the inward shift of the investment function has been so large that it outweighs the effect of the movement along the investment function which should have followed from the drop in the rate of interest.
It’s pretty hard to argue with this take, but that doesn’t mean that we have the kind of understanding which we need for policy purposes. The Bank of Canada, for example, would need to go beyond sketching out what has probably happened and come up with some estimates of the elasticities involved. That means doing some econometrics (although we don’t need, here, to go into the kind of technical depths which the Bank routinely plumbs).
The first thing we need to think about is what functions we want to estimate. If we’re thinking in AD/AS terms we need to go beyond simply talking about estimating the investment function, we need to think about three broad categories of investment – investment in fixed capital, investment in housing, and inventory investment. If we were sticking to a Keynesian Cross model we wouldn’t worry so much about the distinction, since we’d only be looking for Aggregate Demand effects, but when we’re thinking in AD/AS terms we need to recognize that, since fixed capital investment adds to the productive capital stock and so will shift the AS curve, whereas the other two categories will only have AD effects. Then we need to recognize that while all three categories will be functions of the rate of interest, not only will they respond differently to interest rate changes but the other explanatory variables will differ across the categories. For example, net fixed capital investment will respond to expectations about the future level of economic activity while inventory investment will respond partly to expectations but also to changes in current activity. Goods which had been produced for sale will be added to inventory if sales fall short of expectations – basically, unplanned inventory investment can arise very easily but it’s hard to make an argument for unplanned fixed capital investment. And in all three cases of investment we need to make some allowance for lagged responses to changes in things like interest rates.
None of that requires terribly elaborate econometric analysis, but if we want to get a sense of where the neutral interest rate is likely to be, numerically, it would be worthwhile to start by pulling down quarterly national accounts data, and interest rate data, and doing some first-pass estimation of equations for the three categories of investment individually.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.