The result is that supporters of various different flavours of MMT and their critics (including critics among their fellow post-Keynesians) seem to spend most of their time talking past each other. Much of the debate (on all sides) is framed in terms of slogans and the Twitter equivalent of soundbites.
A key area of dispute is in the relation between the rate of growth of the money supply and the rate of inflation – critics cite Zimbabwe, Venezuela and the Weimer Republic, proponents ask why those critics don’t talk about the more recent experience of Japan and the United States, where Quantitative Easing on a large scale has not even pushed inflation up to the Fed’s 2% target. As David Andolfatto has observed it’s true that the MMTers don’t have a good theory of inflation, but these days, who does? (Andolfatto's also critical of the way MMT tends to be characterized, especially in the recent Chicago Booth survey.)
Still, history’s not on the side of the MMTers on this one. The earliest paper money was that issued in China in Marco Polo’s day. Marco Polo was very enthusiastic about the idea; unfortunately he didn’t stick around long enough to see inflation arise as a result of over-issue of the paper money, and units of the currency itself become pretty much worthless.
Most of the basic intro-macro textbook arguments we make have been shaken by the QE episode, and we haven’t done a good job of explaining to the broader public why that is. As a result we aren’t well placed to set out criticisms of MMT. So let’s see what we can piece together about MMT.
MMT, as its name implies, starts from a concept of the money supply. A lot of their writing invokes the concept of sovereign money, by which they mean that money is a creation of government and that what backs it – makes it valuable – is the fact that it can be used to pay taxes, and in fact that it is the only thing which can be used to pay your taxes. This is a view which MMT shares with the Fiscal Theory of the Price Level (FTPL) which is espoused by John Cochrane. FTPL theorists seem to have no objection to the existence of non-state moneys circulating alongside government money: it’s not clear whether MMT assumes state money has a monopoly. In any event, both theories use the term money to refer to state money.
MMT theorists are quite clear that their theory applies only to polities which can print their own sovereign money. Thus MMT does yield policy prescriptions for the state or provincial level. The fact that the money the state prints is the only thing which can be used to pay taxes seems to be essential to MMT policy prescriptions. Without that, there would seem to be no obstacle to private monies circulating alongside, and completely displacing, state money. The need to be able to issue money at will presumably means that MMT wouldn’t work in the gold standard era, and for it to work in a pure bank credit setting such as that discussed by Wicksell or by Keynes in the Treatise on Money would seem to require that the central bank act as the clearing house, with unfettered power to create clearing balances. This, combined with some MMTers apparent view that there’s no need for government financial instruments beyond money, suggests that if the central bank did have a balance sheet it would be a pretty notional concept. I think it’s safe to say that the characterization of MMT as merging the monetary and fiscal authorities under the single heading of Government is valid. There’s no notion of central bank independence here, but given the way MMT sees the economy as working, that’s not a significant flaw, from their perspective.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.