Stephen Poloz made an observation, both in his University of Alberta lecture and also in his final appearance before the Senate National Finance Committee as Governor of the Bank that part of
the reason the Bank was buying large quantities of government bonds from
financial institutions (as distinct from the ones it’s buying from the
government in the primary market) had to do with large firms drawing down their
lines of credit. There’s more (out of
the US) on this phenomenon here as well as a VoxEU post on it here and a (pretty technical) National
Bureau of Economic Research working paper on it here.
The basic idea is that one thing which a lot of firms
learned in 2008 was that if you waited until they were in financial difficulty
to all on their lines of credit with their banks, they could find their access truncated
by banks which were worried about their own ability to support those
loans. So this time they decided to draw
on their lines of credit as soon as the first signs of trouble, rather than
wait and see how things played out.
So they’re drawing on their credit – borrowing – but they’re
not spending those funds on new investment projects, rather they’re depositing
them in their banks – the same ones they’re getting the funds from – in order
to ensure that the cash is there should they need it to support their regular
activities. They’ll be paying interest
on it, but they reckon that’s better than finding that it’s not there when they
need it.
These are odd types of loans from the banks perspective –
the money’s appearing in deposits, as normally happens when they make a loan,
but it’s not being spent to cover gaps between payments and receipts, for
example – it’s just sitting there. This
is happening at a time when the commercial banks are making very large provisions for bad loans.
In the US, that’s
putting pressure on banks’ reserves, even though the fed has actually
eliminated reserve requirements. Since
banks aren’t sure about the solvency of their assets – the loans they had been
making before the pandemic began – they will want to hold reserves well in
excess of any requirement in any event.
The Fed wants them to lend, the banks want to make sure they don’t get
into trouble because any hint that a bank’s having problems can trigger a bank
run.
So a big part of the reason that the Bank of Canada has been
buying government bonds from the banks is to reassure them about their access
to cash which, it is hoped, will make them feel more comfortable about
providing their clients with the cash needed to keep day to day operations
going.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.